In all geologic time, the responsibilities are on our generation ... including you ...

Probes to Asteroids, Near Earth Objects, and Comets

Governmental space agencies have visited many asteroids and comets, though no private entities have done so as of this writing, 2013.

A private entity, or even a small country, could send a probe to an asteroid by using a similar design, and at a lower cost if they can gain access to the designs and equipment off the shelf rather than reinvent the wheel on the preceding research. The same applies to lunar polar probes, and getting a piece of the action ... or a piece of the infrastructure ... for the upcoming lunar polar land rush and resources competition.

The cost of a private asteroid or lunar polar probe mission could easily be less than $100 million, which is much smaller than countless other projects on Earth of questionable value, especially various military equipment expenditures.

The best Near Earth Object targets might be those which telescopic spectroscopy indicates may be volatile rich bodies.

The list of probes below include flybys, long time visits, and sample returns of:

  • Asteroids of all kinds, because they give us some up close information on asteroids, even if these asteroids are not of interest due to their location or composition

  • Comets, as many NEOs are thought to be comets captured into near Earth orbit but which have lost their outer volatiles, and may still have plenty of subsurface volatiles

As noted in other sections, near Earth objects which are burnt out comets are thought to have a thin crust with rich quantities of volatiles under the surface. Other asteroids which originated in the inner solar system can range from pure rock (unattractive) to pure metal, and many grades in between.

The asteroids and comets visited to date are generally not the most economically attractive bodies, and were chosen my scientists for other reasons. The potential for mining such bodies was not considered in the selection process of any of these targets.

Nonetheless, we have developed and flight tested many technologies useful for asteroid prospecting.

It is much easier to fly pass an asteroid or comet (or move to where they will fly past you) than it is to match their orbit and land on them.

The cost of probes capable of prospecting asteroids has come down dramatically. For example, The NASA NEAR (Near Earth Asteroid Rendezvous) probe currently en route to the asteroid Eros which it will study for a year cost 150 million dollars to design, produce, launch and operate. Making and launching another copy of it will cost even less since the design costs are already done and the component manufacturers have already developed their manufacturing capability and billed the US government for it. In fact, government projects are not cost-efficient at all compared to private sector operations. If we produce multiple copies of the same probe, the cost comes down even further.

The company SpaceDev brought the estimated cost down to under $50 million, back in the late 1990s for their NEAP probe (Near Earth Asteroid Prospector), thought they didn't find any buyers at that time. Microsatellite technology has come a long way since that time.

A private launch would become more feasible if the originally sponsoring government agreed to save money by letting a private entity underwrite the mission with a guaranteed government purchase of some of the scientific data, similar to an X-Prize, though the mission underwriter may want to keep some of the data to itself for mining purposes.

We can also study asteroids from the ground and Earth orbit by telescopes, to get a general idea about the asteroids' surfaces. However, telescopic spectroscopy gives us only average spectra and not detailed information.

Ultimately, we need some "49ers" to go prospecting for asteroids, much as American settlers went to California looking for gold in the 1849 gold rush. These 49ers could benefit from the designs of the existing or planned government-sponsored spacecraft, and even employ their human designers and their organizations if feasible. After all, government probes and contractors are paid for with taxpayer dollars, and thus the information is available to the public. Also, some of the people working on those projects may be interested in working for a private venture to an asteroid.


The following sections cover only government funded probes. No private sector probes have been sent to an asteroid, though this may change soon. The private sector probes will be put into the Missions section instead of within this Asteroids section since the emphasis there is business and sustainability (though they may be moved here later).

The probes below are ordered by date of launch, not arrival, since many probes visited more than one asteroid or comet.

This section covers only probes, not telescopes. For the history and future of the latter, see the PERMANENT section on telescopes discovering and characterizing asteroids




PERMANENT.com > Asteroids, Near Earth Objects (NEO) > Probes to Asteroids and NEOs

Additional, children pages of this current parent page:

Probes to Asteroids and NEOs :
  Phobos, Deimos (Mars moons)
  Giotto (Halleys Comet)
  MBA Galileo flybys
  Clementine 1
  NEAR-Shoemaker
  Deep Space 1
  Stardust
  Hayabusa NEA Sample Return
  Rosetta Comet Lander, Orbiter
  Deep Impact (Comet)
  Dawn to MBA Vesta, Ceres
  Fobos-Grunt (failed, Phobos)
  OSIRIS-REx Asteroid Probe
  Obama-Keck asteroid retrieval




To get updates on PERMANENT (occasional, not frequent), get on our mailing list.

For general or specific e-mail regarding PERMANENT, please use our Feedback page.

Leave information about yourself in our people, companies, and organizations database.

If you are interested in hiring our expertise, anywhere in the world, please contact us.
We have people in the USA and Thailand, and can travel or consult by internet.
You can call anytime, 24/7, at +66-8-1135-7977

Text by Mark Prado, Copyright © 1983-2013, All Rights Reserved.
Many website artistic design elements by Sam Fraser, Copyright © 1999-2013, All Rights Reserved.

Except where specifically stated otherwise,
Copyright © 1983-2013 by Mark Evan Prado, All Rights Reserved

Source: http://www.permanent.com

PERMANENT logo
P rojects to E mploy R esources of the M oon and A steroids N ear E arth in the N ear T erm

Menu:
please see our

Site Map

to navigate.

For PCs, this righthand
side has a floating menu,
but if your tablet
or your PCs web browser
do not run
-- javascript --
then you must
-- navigate --
using the Site Map above.